TRADITIONAL FORMWORK SYSTEM COMPARISION
Specification | Wood | Metal | Desire |
---|---|---|---|
Reusability | 5 - 10 Times | 20-50 Times | Over 100 Times |
Surface Quality | Good, |
Good, Degrades (rust and deformation) |
Excellent |
Weight/Manageablity | Average (10Kg/sq.mt) |
Heavy 31Kg/sq.mt) |
Very Lightweight 6.75Kg/sq.mt) |
Safety | Average | Dangerous | Excellent |
Maintenance Cost | N/A | High | Negligible |
Recycleability | Cannot be recycled Wasteful and difficult to dispose |
At least 25% | At least 20% |
Storage | Store in warehouse |
Store in warehouse to prevent weathering |
No warehouse required |
Transportation | Average | Problem | Excellent |
Eco Friendly | No | No | Yes |
Versatility | No | No | Yes |
Cost of use minimum 1.0 sq.mt | 31.11 | 31.67 | 17.74 |
Labor Attitude | Not friendly (skill labor) | Friendly (Not skill labor) | Friendly (Not skill labor) |
Release-agents Spray require | Yes | Yes | No |
Even after high Numbers of reuses, |
No | No | Yes |
Used wooden scaffolding system | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Used Acro span scaffolding system | Yes | Yes | Yes |
INTERNATIONAL FORMWORK SYSTEM COMPARISION
Specification | Reusability | Reusability | Meva | GEO Panel | DOKA | Desire |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Reusability | Over 100 Times | Over 100 Times | Over 100 Times | Over 100 Times | Over 100 Times | |
Surface Quality | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
Weight/Manageability | Heavy weight (+/- 20kg/sq.mt) |
Very lightweight (+/- 7kg/sq.mt) |
Heavy weight 3S panel(+/-10.5kg/sq.mt) MD panel(+/-20kg/sq.mt) |
Heavy weight (+/- 16.15kg/sq.mt) |
Very lightweight (+/-6.75kg/sq.mt) |
|
Assembly and stripping | By Crane without Crane |
By Hand without Crane |
By Hand without Crane |
By Hand without Crane |
By Crane | By Hand |
Safety | Good | Excellent | Good | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
Maintenance Cost | Average | Low | Average | Low | Average | Negligible |
Recycle ability | At least 20% | At least 20% | At least 20% | At least 20% | N/A | At least 20% |
Storage | Store in warehouse to prevent weathering |
No warehouse required |
Store in warehouse to prevent weathering |
Does not to be store in a dry environment |
Store in warehouse to prevent weathering |
No warehouse required |
Transportation | Good | Excellent | Good | Good | Good | Excellent |
Eco Friendly | No | Yes | No | Yes | No | Yes |
Versatility | No | No | No | No | No | Yes |
Cost of use minimum 1.0 sq.mt |
166.67 | 17.74 | ||||
Labor attitude | Not friendly (skill labor) |
Not friendly (skill labor) |
Not friendly (skill labor) |
Not friendly (skill labor) |
Not friendly (skill labor) |
Friendly (Not skill labor) |
Release agents spray require |
Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
Used wooden Scaffolding systems |
No | No | No | No | No | Yes |
Used Acro Span Scaffolding systems |
No Used own system |
No Used own system |
No Used own system |
No Used own system |
No Used own system |
Yes |